Title: Tara and Willow – Coulda, Woulda, Shoulda – Chapter Twenty-One Author: Katharyn Rosser Feedback: Absolutely, yes please. That’s why I write for this place, to engage in the discussion about the story. Spoiler warning: Not sure why I am bothering, really, but Season 4 and Season 5 of BTVS. Distribution: This story was written for Pens. Pens is its home. No archiving off Different Coloured Pens and the Kitten Board please. No conversion to eBook or other formats please. Enjoy it here. Summary: Moving through the events of Hush with both the girls. Disclaimer: I don’t own any of the copyrights or anything else associated with BTVS. All rights lie with the production company, writers etc. I am making no money from this series of stories however all original characters and situations remain my property. As this is a missing scenes and alternate reality fiction lots of scenes are new versions of those seen in the show, as such dialogue and situations are taken from the show. I’m sure you can tell which. All credit for those aspects goes to the original writers. Rating: Occasional, tasteful, adult situations and contextual bad language. However by and large equivalent to the show. Couples: Tara and Willow forever, that’s all I’m bothered about. Text convention: Use of italics denotes either special emphasis if used for a single or a few words in a sentence OR first person thoughts if used for a whole sentence. Notes: As mentioned previously I’m trying to keep things somewhat similar to the way it happened in canon because I don’t want to lose those special moments entirely, but there are differences in how this plays out… I figure that there are just some places that there are supposed to be visited though. What it does mean though – since we’re only in Tara and Willow’s viewpoints, is that we lose track of other things going on. We’ll get to hear about them later though and – be honest, they’re the best thing about Hush anyway… Thanks to: The Gentlemen. Cos you wouldn’t want to tick them off, would you?
Giles, fortunately, had found one of those marker pens that rubbed off. If he’d mistakenly used one of those permanent ones, for what he was doing now then… Well, there’d have been trouble.
The boards – she had a portable one hung around her neck – were their main means of communication. That and charades. Slightly less than strict-observance of Hanukkah traditions in the Rosenberg House came into their own. Way to go, Dad.
At the moment Giles was using the board to put questions out there. “Can we be sure it wasn’t the Wicca Group, summoning?” he’d written. Willow shook her head and Giles indicated with a shrug that he wasn’t sure whether she was saying she couldn’t be sure or the answer was that it wasn’t the Wicca Group.
“Not Wicca,” she wrote. “Not last night.”
That girl, Tara had said ‘hi’ to her, smiled and there was nothing else going on there. She was sure of that. Certainly nothing that had students being mutilated in their beds. No way and no how was that smile of Tara’s a part of that. Uhuh. And she’d stayed for the whole thing. There’d been no strange rituals at all. Period.
“Goddess?” Buffy asked, tugging the board – and Willow too – towards her to get the question down on her board. She’d have said ‘buy your own’ but she had no voice.
Willow shrugged when she figured out the upside down scrawl. It was always possible that some sort of sacrifice was going on, that was true. They just didn’t know.
Interesting though that they were treating the Wicca Group and the so-called Goddess who was leading it as separate questions.
I’m Willow Rosenberg, and I approve of this distinction.
Pulling her face, she thought about it a little more. She couldn’t be sure it wasn’t Diana or Artemis or whatever her name was, but she didn’t have any reason to think it was either. After all, weird and dangerous stuff had been happening in Sunnydale for years and years before the Goddess got here.
She shook her head, but then shrugged again. Trying to show him she meant ‘Could be, but I don’t think so.’
This non-verbal conversation thing was hard.
That judgement seemed to be enough for Giles though. In fact he seemed to welcome it. “Then I believe I know what it is,” he wrote and then turned to his projector and put some pre-drawn slides onto it, shining them up onto the screen where he’d been writing his words with the fortunate choice of pens.
Clearly he’d had the suspicion long before asking her for her opinion on the alternatives. That was the thing, a supposed Goddess in town – one collaborating with would-be witches – turned all their usual assumptions upside down. Research alone wasn’t enough, not at the moment anyway.
This little performance though, she could tell it was born of research. And she approved of that too. This was how research should be presented, when you had a captive – ignorant – audience. Willow watched with interest as a little music played and Giles recounted the story of something called ‘The Gentlemen’.
Without any reference to Goddesses or sweet, smiling girls, you could see the myth he was referring to unfold. Tall men who cut out hearts just… well, seemingly just because they could. Monsters who took away the ability to scream first so that no one would be warned and – ooh, they were vulnerable to a scream too. That was what it was all about then.
How you got all of the voices in the town into this little box though… that she wasn’t so sure of the scientific basis for. But she’d learned it was best not to probe too deeply into the science behind the legends. Usually because things just didn’t work that way.
And sometimes because it was just better not to ask. Just go with the fact it was magic and… kind of a cool idea. Even if the reason for it was all macabre.
So… what did they do now?
Well, the first thing she wanted suggest was always having a audio-visual element to their briefings because that was way cool. But… what was that Buffy was suggesting…?
Okay…
Well, her roomate seemed to have something rather… umm, obscene in mind. A new strategy, one that they probably wouldn’t have seen coming – no pun intended - but, you know, whatever worked. Giving them that kind of a happy didn’t seem to be the best idea though…
Perhaps Buffy needed a boyfriend?
Oooh, she meant slay them? Yeah, that made a little more sense now.
After that, get the box with the voices. Break the box. Get the voice back and then… scream until they popped like an overripe zit? Obvious really, why hadn’t she thought of that?
After all it seemed… Well, it was a bit derivative. It sounded a little like that movie with the martians. The one with the cute girl as the President’s daughter. But… hey, it was a fairy tale and more often than not those things turned out to have some basis in fact. Except this one was kind of… well, eww too. And a lot of them were. Those Grimm’s, they were just freaks.
Or very well informed.
Maybe both.
“Who hunts for them?” Willow wrote.
Buffy pointed at herself.
“Just you?”
“It’s what I do.” The hand gestures that were supposed to demonstrate the ‘Slayer thing’ were, once again unfortunate, and everyone could read Buffy’s lips when she mouthed, ‘Oh, for God’s sake.’
----------------
Diana was apparently the only person who could speak after what the news was saying was an epidemic afflicting the whole town. Of course it wasn’t the news that had revealed Diana’s ability to speak, but rather the sudden use of a voice that Tara found so shocking.
Good job, really. After the deaths of two students Tara had been reluctant to open her door just because someone knocked on it.
That was a strange thing that people like her, who knew some of the reality of the supernatural world, would ever think that a door would really keep out the bad things. But Diana’s voice had been reassuring all the same and not just so she’d open her door.
Just to hear someone talking was a reassurance. Reporters had tried it, anyone who even entered town after the fact – whatever that was - was still losing their voice and so a quarantine zone had been set up around Sunnydale.
It might not have been a bad idea to leave it there all the time, after all this place was… interesting.
But from Diana’s explanation, there was no disease or illness. What was happening was both simpler and more disquieting.
Naturally enough – or supernaturally enough – there was nothing new under the sun as far as the Goddess was concerned. Knowing the symptoms and the events that had occurred Diana had quickly come to her conclusion.
What worried Tara a little was that, having come to that conclusion, Diana came to her.
Hearing the reason though… “It is one of mine that they’ve taken,” the Goddess had said, which explained at least a part of it.
Clearly to take anything from her was an assault on the priveleges that she felt she was owed.
Tara tried to look quizzical while she hunted for a piece of paper and a paper. Did Diana even read English? There was something going on, something not quite normal, when it came to speaking with and understanding her but… reading what was written down?
“I forget that you cannot speak.”
As Diana would’ve said, ‘Ever has it been so’, Tara mused. She was more used to silence than most. Keeping quiet was one of her strongest and most frequently used qualities.
“They took one of mine and I knew it at once,” Diana continued. “Assurance was required that it was not you who had been lost.”
It only took a moment to decide what she must mean. And having heard that one of the butchered students who’d had their heart removed was a fellow member of the Wicca Group, Tara felt a little sick. On the other hand, the Goddess was surely her strongest protector at this moment and had taken special care to come and make sure she was okay.
Which was both nice and… worrying. So she nodded, yes, she was fine.
“It is a grave insult,” Diana said. “From those who once knew better.”
Tara shrugged, trying to show that she didn’t know what they were talking about.
Some words that Tara would’ve found unpronounceable on a good day and embarrassing on a bad one tumbled from Diana’s lips, but then a translation. “The last centuries have mistakenly named them ‘The Gentlemen’ perhaps because of their current visage. Unlike the rest they are not drawn here, they are simply passing through. Next week they will be somewhere else and then somewhere else after that.”
‘Gentlemen’ didn’t sound too bad, but what they’d done… Suddenly her mind turned to Willow Rosenberg, Stevenson Hall. Was she okay? Was she holed up somewhere? She couldn’t have been one of the… victims, could she? No, both of them had been guys. That was what the news had said.
This time.
And there were lots of people in Sunnydale, lots more on the campus. The chance of something happening to Willow was… Well, it was less now that the Goddess considered the whole of the Wicca Group to be under protection.
‘What do we do?’ Tara wanted to ask, but whatever it was that allowed them to understand each other clearly didn’t work with words that hadn’t actually been spoken out loud. Going through the motions of doing that wasn’t the same thing.
“Fear not, Tara. They would depart in days if left alone, but their insult cannot go unanswered. I am the Goddess of the Hunt, and I will have them. But in this I require your assistance.”
Not at all wary, given the fact that people were dying and one of them might be her if she shook her head, Tara nodded immediately. She had to do what she could. Up to now anything Diana had done had been more of a demonstration – albeit ones that made things better for people, killing demons and vampires. But to actually help? That was something new and… the Goddess needed her help.
Nodding again, she hoped she was showing that she was eager to do what was necessary.
----------------------
Being left behind by Buffy wasn’t exactly a new experience. It happened. While they were pretty blasé about vampires these days – easy come easy go – there were other things that went bump in the night which were much harder to deal with.
Or maybe they just had no real idea how to make them go away in a very final manner so research needed to be done.
Or – as in this case – they knew the how, there was just some question about the when and the where… Someone needed to find a box and that someone wasn’t her.
So Buffy was out there and she was back here… keeping the home fires burning. Except there were no fires.
Actually, that wasn’t quite true. There was a fire. A fire inside her… Not the kind that needed indigestion remedies either. This was a fire of… what? She didn’t even know what was combusting. The oxygen though… the oxygen, that was… well, she couldn’t get that girl out of her head.
Tara.
There were too many thoughts that she didn’t really understand.
No, that wasn’t really it. Admitting it to herself was the only way she was going to get it. She understood those thoughts quite well actually. They were just… unusual.
‘Unusual’. Yeah, that was a good way of putting it. If she’d been able to talk then she’d have said it out loud right then. Tested out the sound of the word in this context. ‘Unusual.’ Meaning, of course, ‘not usual.’
Not ‘bad’. Noooo, not bad. Nothing that felt like this was going to be bad. It was just… not usual.
She tried saying it, knowing that she wouldn’t hear herself but feeling the way her tongue moved. ‘Unusual.’ Again, testing how her tongue moved against the front and roof of mouth. No tooth contact.
Which was a strange thing to be focusing on, what with everything else that was happening.
But see, with everything else going on, she was excited about something that wasn’t going to happen for several days. The next Wicca Group she was totally, totally, going to say something. Out loud. And more than ‘Hi.’ To Tara.
‘Hi’ had been good. ‘Hi’ was a good start.
All of this, of course, assumed she got her voice back.
That was something else though.
But while – for once in her life – she felt absolutely no need to rationalise everything, she did have to wonder where these… feelings were coming from.
Feelings. She was feeling feelings. That was what made them feelings. That you could feel them. And yes, she was feeling them.
Serial killers – monster serial killers – were on the loose and she was already anticipating the next meeting with Tara? What was up with that?
The need to say something and for it to be the right thing was high in her mind. The ‘right’ thing was something she’d usually gotten to by sheer volume of words on the basis that – eventually – some combination of them would do the job. ‘Babble’ if you like but… it usually worked. You know, if you could get the words into the right order. The rest was just editing.
And understanding.
So, that was another feeling she was having. Worry.
Worry about not saying the right thing. Worry about saying the wrong thing. Worry about not saying anything much that was intelligible and…
Nothing else.
For a few hours there she had tried to find other reasons behind what she was thinking about. But in the end she’d had to accept a fairly self-evident truth. She – Willow Rosenberg - thought the girl from the Wicca Group – Tara - was beautiful.
Not in the way that Christy Turlington was beautiful (and untouchable). Not like the ‘popular girls’ from high school packaged themselves in expensive clothes, a pound of make-up and shiny hair so they could consider themselves the ‘beautiful people’ deserving of everyone else’s fawning…
No. Beautiful in the sense of being… well, beautiful.
Tara was beautiful like… ‘I want to be close to her because she’s just beautiful.’
And it was the ‘I want to be close to her’ part that was shiny and new and like totally unexpected. That was something she’d never, ever, felt before. Not that way, not for that reason… That it was about a girl hadn’t even stirred her all that much and she’d wondered why that was until she realised it didn’t matter, but...
There it was.
She’d been left alone, with the risk that some evil creature would come to cut out her heart while she couldn’t even scream and all she could actually think about was how she was having… Well, there was really no denying it. She was having a girl crush.
Except it wasn’t just a crush if you were actually planning to do something about it. Wanted to do something about it.
And she was. She did.
The weird thing – and it absolutely wasn’t anything to do with the fact this was a girl she was talking about – the weird thing was that she had absolutely no fear of the ‘doing something about it’ part.
Now that really was weird and totally out of character. Of course, she still had several days to get very, very nervous. But right now… That smile told her everything she needed to know. The girl wouldn’t laugh at her, get offended or start accusing her of anything. If she was making a mistake then Tara would – what? She’d probably smile and be nice about it. The smile would still be lovely and help with the disappointment.
And if she wasn’t making a mistake then Tara was… beautiful.
Beautiful defined.
While that was a new concept, it certainly wasn’t a disturbing one. Because… well, Tara was at the other end of it. The shift was curious, but the anticipated outcome certainly wasn’t…
Which left her with dozens of unanswered questions and one very appealing way to find some of the answers.
Like, what would it be like to kiss a girl?
Scratch that – what would it be like to kiss Tara? Put her lips against those lips and just kiss her?
Didn’t matter what research she could have done, that was a question that could only be answered by, you know, actually doing it. And if Tara was - well, statistically there had to be a bigger chance that she was into girls if she was hanging out in that Wicca group. Not wanting to stereotype and all and it wasn’t true for everyone blah-blah but the important thing to know was whether – well, whether…
Would Tara like to kiss her?
It’d be jumping the gun to imagine that Tara had smiled at her that way because she wanted to kiss her – they’d only just met after all - but… She very much liked to think she’d have smiled the same, shy way if that had been what was in her head at that very moment.
She’d never had cause to believe in love at first sight and she wasn’t going to put that burden on what she was feeling right now either. ‘Love’ was a long, long way to go on the back of one meeting and one smile.
But what I wouldn’t give to have the chance – and the voice – to ask if I could kiss her.
More importantly though…
What I wouldn’t give to see that smile right now. It’d make everything seem better…
-----------------
Bait.
She was bait now?
Apparently these things – these ‘Gentlemen’ - were… Well, ‘cruel’ was one way of putting it. They liked to rub salt into the wound. They liked a chase… they enjoyed the fear as much as whatever they wanted hearts for.
And though Diana had asked her to draw their attention, even though the Goddess was – presumably – protecting her, Tara’s fear was very real.
Where to go? What to do?
Now that she was fleeing from the immaculately dressed creatures, floating along in the wake of their lumbering – but deceptively quick - minions, she had the question of where she was supposed to go. More than once Callisto or Jupiter had leapt and picked off the chain rattling creatures that had been gaining on her but only when they’d already gotten way too close.
The Gentlemen seemed unconcerned about the loss of their helpers though and just kept after her, seeming content to tire her out and wear her down so they could enjoy what they intended to do…
Where to go? She probably wasn’t built for long distance running but maybe now was the time to think about taking the sport up – if she was going to be staying here. More importantly for now she wasn’t dressed for it either.
But maybe the destination had never really been in doubt and that explained it.
After all, she’d been getting ready for it before she came out. If Annie had been surprised to be asked – via pieces of paper – what she should wear for what wasn’t a date but could easily be a proto-date meeting then she hadn’t said much. And not just because neither of them had any voice.
It’d seemed like her dorm mate had actually appreciated the chance for some company – everyone was afraid and most people had no idea what was happening. Eventually Tara had left Annie there, wrapped in her comforter on her bed.
It appeared her locks seemed more secure to Annie… even though she couldn’t promise when she’d be back.
But she had to say that she approved of the choice’s Annie had made, given the limited wardrobe available. See, she’d decided that she did have to go see Willow Rosenberg at Stevenson Hall. And she knew that she wanted to make the right impression when she did that.
It couldn’t be a date and she just didn’t do ‘slutty’ as Annie had put it on paper. So… what to wear? Jeans might’ve been more practical, especially when she’d fallen on her butt, but the skirt was… It was feminine, modest but said ‘yeah, I have curves. Do you like them?’
But without the desperate edge of ‘Please say you like them’.
At least that was what Annie had suggested by way of expressive hand gestures.
The top was designed for the same, didn’t show off her chest that much but when Annie had insisted that she better pick her intimates out carefully, you know, just in case… When she did that… well, it was something Tara hadn’t actually thought about. It wasn’t like she was a regular at Victoria’s Secret and she just didn’t get along with thongs and anything that rode up where it shouldn’t do. But… she had some nice things and had gone along with Annie’s suggestion without being directly guided by her. But the boots were Annie’s final touch.
Yeah, she liked them, she really did. They were comfy and though not built for speed, they were great for protecting the feet running through a rose bush when you had to hike up your skirt or tear it, but they also said ‘Yeah, you know what I like.’
Again, that was Annie’s – written - interpretation. For a straight woman she had remarkable insight into what you might call ‘alternative fashions’…
Or did she? Maybe it wasn’t so good. And maybe this wasn’t the time to be worrying about it. Time and events would tell… Hopefully.
Maybe Willow would like the boots or not, there was more for her to worry about. Like the fact that now she was sweaty, tired, scratched – in spite of the boots – and there was pretty good chance that there was a big dirty mark on her butt.
Best laid plans and all that… Maybe trying to meet Willow tonight and being Diana’s bait should’ve been mutually exclusive. But… in a crisis like this, she had the chance to do some good in both. That Willow was powerful and knew her way around magic had never been in doubt for her, so between them surely they could come up with something that could help, even if Diana didn’t manage to take down the Gentlemen on her own?
When might that kind of urgency be on them again? It was a great excuse.
No, not an excuse. It was a great reason to talk to Willow. A brilliant way not to seem like a creepy stalker for finding her and going to her… Any other time? Well, she could’ve waited for the next Wicca Group, but such a delay didn’t seem very appealing.
But out of breath as she was now, not even daring to look back and having to put her trust in the Goddess and her hounds, the delay was looking like a better and better idea.
She was at Stevenson though, she’d made it and burst through the doors which – even in this emergency – were blessedly unlocked.
It was only a few second before she heard them clatter open and closed again though.
Just once…
Only one of them after her then? That was better than two or three. Diana must’ve really taken a number of them down already.
On the other hand one was likely to be more than enough. Maybe now it was down to her to defend herself. And Willow?
Please, Willow Rosenberg, just be there.
What exactly they’d do about this – together - she wasn’t sure, hopefully Diana would’ve taken care of things by then but… if she didn’t, or if Diana was dealing with those others that had been after her then… She and Willow Rosenberg would have to find a way.
Somehow.
Without words…
Two of them had a better chance than one though and –
I’m putting her in danger but… she’s already in danger.
Up one flight of stairs and then another, Tara pushed ahead and went past a room from which there were no screams but certainly nothing natural was happening beyond the door. Nothing cracked that way except…
She didn’t want to imagine it, but she was.
Be there. Be there. Be there. Be there. I didn’t want to lead them to your door but be there, I need you to be there. Be there, please…
Maybe these things had more trouble with stairs than the flat, because she seemed to have found some more time as she started to bang on the door. She had to keep looking, even though she didn’t want to. Were they there? Were they right there about to grab her? Looking and banging. Banging and looking.
Please…
Yes!
Eventually the door did open and a very shocked Willow Rosenberg was stood there. Shocked? Shocked why? Did she know what was happening? Surprised at the state her visitor was in? Tara knew she must look a mess. Or… had Willow Rosenberg been thinking about her at all?
Why the door opened and why the other girl looked as shocked as she did didn’t really matter though. Not now.
Somehow Willow intuited the need to not just shut the door in her face, or even pull her inside with her but instead to set off and run… That was what they needed to do. It was obvious that the Gentlemen had no trouble at all dealing with doors. But then evil, undead, supernatural surgeons probably wouldn’t find that too complicated.
She’d brought them here and put everyone – but especially Willow Rosenberg – in more immediate danger but Willow didn’t seem to care about that. Maybe she hadn’t thought about it yet. Right now, they were together and they were doing what they had to.
That was running, running, running. Running until they couldn’t run anymore they’d got away from these terrible creatures.
Being with Willow, touching her and holding her hand for the first time came with a rush of power and sameness that she’d barely experienced since Momma passed. That on its own gave her a second wind and even though she’d been running to get here, and up the stairs, she was more than able to keep pace with Willow. She was even able to pull and hurry her along.
Not that the red-haired young woman needed any encouragement once she looked back and saw… horror.
Running down the halls, Tara thought she saw… Was that one of the dogs? She didn’t slow down to look – something large and black though. But she was only sure when the other – Jupiter - stepped out in front of them, dominating the hallway, Willow was the one to slow down, wary of the canine and probably not without reason.
Tara shook her head; telling her it was okay and pulled Willow along, past Jupiter who was so focused on his task – growling softly at what was following them – that he wasn’t even acknowledged.
“Thanks to you, Tara,” Diana said, stepping out beside her hound and turning her attention to Willow Rosenberg, if only briefly. “Take your friend somewhere else. Secure the doors. This one will tell me where the box is.”
Both she and Willow looked back, saw the perpetually grinning creature. But despite the grin it looked shocked, worried and even… apologetic when it looked down the hallway.
It knew who Diana was then? And it was… worried…?
The Goddess, however, wasn’t in a ‘no harm, no foul’ mood and turned her full attention to the creature that was chasing them. The growl of the dogs cut through the silence – they weren’t affected either - and Tara pulled Willow behind her, figuring that one dorm block had to be built like any other at least in so far as there’d be more secure rooms downstairs – or rooms that they could make more secure.
Willow was resisting, obviously interested in watching what was about to happen, but Tara tugged twice on her hand to make the point. It wasn’t safe. Diana, at least for a while, was going to be occupied here and that meant she had to get somewhere safer. Get them somewhere safer.
She met the other girl’s eyes and, rather than getting lost in them which would’ve been really easy, tried to show that there was a place they should be instead. Willow acquiesced and took the lead, taking her down corridors and the stairwell, down into the basement where they almost ran smack into one of the lumbering minions.
It stood there, looking momentarily as surprised as they were, facing them with chains hanging from its straitjacket. Long moments passed while both sides wondered what to do.
They looked at each other and then ran the other way and into what turned out to be the laundry room. Tara looked and found no lock, but one glance at Willow - what she’d found - and they came to some silent agreement over what should happen. The tingle of their connection while they were holding hands flared into life and -
Neither of them had made a ‘decision’ it was just… obvious and necessary to the combined pair that the magic within had made them while they were physically linked. With a flick of their eyes the giant soda machine that had rested in the corner flung itself across the floor, leaving scars in the linoleum and hitting with a resounding thud that said nothing was coming through that door until they decided otherwise.
And so, locked in the laundry together, Tara’s mind didn’t turn to what the Goddess was doing.
She was entirely focused on the girl who’s hand she was holding…
The grip might’ve softened and become less urgent, but neither of them seemed willing to let go.
*****************
_________________ ------------------------- If I wanted a little pussy, I've got my own to play with.
Chance in *Chance* -------------------------
|