Skip to content


FIC: The Dark Rose

Author Index - #s, A-M.
This is a forum for Willow and Tara Fan Fiction that is Complete. Please read the content advisories on individual stories, read at your own discretion. You CAN leave feedback!

Chapter 19a replies

Postby darkmagicwillow » Mon Jan 20, 2003 7:54 pm

I'm leaving tomorrow for a couple of weeks, but I'll have the rest of chapter 19 up before I leave. I should still be able to make weekly updates, though I probably won't be able to do twice a week. My replies this week may be a bit short because of being away from home.





Silver: Thanks. I see you're first again.



seurat: I'm glad I've been able to bring you around. I like cerulean, but there's always azure. Hmmm...it's a hard decision for me.



FlereImsaho: It's good to hear that you're back at work, and good to see you back in Pens. I do that reading too fast thing too; writing too for that matter! That's why I write like a painter, going back to add extra coatings of thoughts and details after I've gotten past the initial excitement of the idea.



Insanity: You're right, in Sunnydale there's always another big bad. How am I going to resolve that? (-;



frumpycat: Good. I thought Willow's plan made sense given her character. Perhaps she'll make the same mistakes, just faster, like Xita's quote.



Willow can work without spells as she did in chapter 1 in the null magic area, but she's a witch, not a slayer.



Inward Sea: You'd better let your nails grow a bit before reading chapter 20. (-;



Grimmy: The next scene in this chapter is actually a research one. Don't worry, she's too smart to go in unprepared. And soon you'll know all too much about the strength of the Heart.



Sister Bertrille: Your taste in stories is alarmingly close to mine. (-; I just watched Resident Evil and I'd recommend it to you as it pulls off both of those very well; in fact, it's one of the best zombie movies since George Romero.



I love what you say about each of them being the other's nourishment, though I'm glad I ate before reading your post. That brings to mind another as yet unbridged division: Willow and Tara as two parts of one whole. And yes, they are getting more secure with each other though there are still secrets.



VampNo12: Tara's bringing together both Willow's in her heart and mind, though as you point out she still has reservations. Tara brings Willow the security she needs to make those great strides; what would Willow do without her? As for Keys, I'll have something to say about that soon.



Patches: I'm happy for the meltdown, your joy in the light amidst the shadows. You do have a good point about Willow not appearing to learn from the past. However, her journey is incomplete as you so eloquently explain. She is deeply tempted with the best of reasons in her heart, but she still has choices to make. Amy is a shadow of what Willow could become in her journey if she makes the wrong choice, especially if she lost her hope.



tommo: I'm so happy to read your feedback I'll skip the spiky rocks this time. (-;



For someone who eschews claims of eloquence, you're insightfully articulate with your thoughts and words about identity. You've helped crystallize my understanding of Tara's dilemma in her conflicting feelings of confusion and familiarity.



Your words about Willow describe me as I began writing this, bitter depressiveness about the show and issues in my own life combining to help me be that Willow and write her. Yet things have gotten better in life as well as the story as it's progressed and that gives me hope as I write the ending that it's not just an ending, but also a beginning.



tiredsoul: Thanks, I love it when someone picks out my favorite lines of a chapter and quotes them in their feedback.



vamp nurd: The temptation to let the end justify the means has always been a difficult one for Willow.



Tulipp: Last but certainly not least, you're always able to see so well like you do here, seeing so much in Willow's thoughts. I like the idea of love as creation, a re-creation of not only yourself but also the person you love and the both of you together. And you're right about mirrors; they may be pretty, but they don't always tell the truth.

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

darkmagicwillow
 


Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby darkmagicwillow » Mon Jan 20, 2003 7:58 pm

Title: The Dark Rose - Chapter 19b (Secrets)

Author: Dark Magic Willow

Email: darkmagickwillow@yahoo.com

Rating: R, mostly for violence, no explicit sex

Pairing: W/T

Spoilers: All episodes through the end of season 6 though this story takes place 18-19 years after the end of season 6.

Feedback: Yes! Constructive criticism is always welcome.

Summary: The day after.

Magic Note: Magic, even dark magic, is not addictive in my universe, so there are no withdrawal symptoms and no dark magic dealers. Here Rack was a dark magic teacher who used his students, not a dealer. However, you can use too much magic and you can be corrupted by the power it gives you.

Disclaimer: I don't own any of the copyrights or anything else associated with BtVS. All rights lie with the production company, writers etc.

Acknowledgements: Thanks to Amanda and Juli for all your insight and encouragement.





The Dark Rose

Chapter 19b: Secrets






As Tara entered the school library with Willow, she reflected on how different it seemed this afternoon. The sun was up, the power was on, and better yet there wasn't an army of zombies outside trying to kill them. Still, all wasn't well with the world. Although Giles and Dawn were reading at their usual table, Giles from a book and Dawn from a computer terminal, Spirit was curled up under a blanket in the comfy chair with a heavy tome on her lap. She looked unnaturally pale and shivered as Tara watched.



"Tara," Spirit said as she spotted her. "You're late!" she accused with a smile on her face. "If I can't get out of research like this, then you certainly shouldn't."



"Willow and I spent all morning-" Tara began.



Spirit raised her eyebrows and interrupted her before she could finish. "I'm sure we don't need to know about that," she teased.



Tara let her hair fall forward to hide her face as she blushed. "We were researching," she protested.



Dawn watched the exchange with a smile on her face. "I remember the kind of research you two used to do," she said, compounding Tara's embarrassment. It was good to let some of their tension out this way after what had happened last night. She'd watched over Spirit carefully today as she was worried about the young woman even though she'd just met her last night. Spirit's courage reminded her so much of Buffy, but she seemed so young to be facing that every night.



Giles was relieved that Spirit felt well enough to tease too even though he was unsure about whether Willow and Tara's relationship was a good thing. He interrupted the teasing, trying to keep his voice as neutral as possible as he didn't wish to antagonize Willow. "Did you find anything?"



"We did," Willow answered as she put down the stack of books she was carrying beside Giles. She helped Tara unload her backpack, which was full of more reference tomes. She carefully removed the last item, bundled in layers of cloth, from the backpack and unwrapped the ancient book from its protective covering before handing it directly to Giles.



Giles looked at the book closely before opening it. Turning the pages with reverence he examined the tome closely. "It's the earliest Tacitus I've heard of," he said.



"It's also complete," Willow said with a slightly smug smile.



"But the complete histories have been lost for centuries," Giles protested, as he looked down at the book in wonder.



"Now it's found," Willow said lightly. "It's a gift for you. I know that things between us can't be made suddenly right with a single gesture, but I wanted you to know that I want them to be right." She looked into his eyes, her face open and accepting, willing him to understand what she felt for him, for Dawn, and for all her family.



Giles looked up at Willow, searching for sincerity in her dark eyes. When he finally nodded, accepting the gift with a "Thank you," the tense, worried line on his brow relaxed for the first time since Willow had seen him again in Sunnydale.



Tara saw that there were still reservations in Giles's eyes, but she was happy that things were less tense between the two than last night. She reached over and picked up the most promising of the references they had found, a thin, tattered book. "This one is a journal of someone who found the emerald we saw last night. It's been translated more than once and we're not sure of the exact dates," she said. "I'll read the most interesting entry. It's also the final one." The group at the table gathered around her as she read from the book, while Spirit listened from her chair.





"The experiment was a success beyond our worst nightmares. The Heart's power of resurrection is limitless, but it cannot be harnessed for anyone's benefit. I don't know if the Heart is broken or whether it was simply evil from the beginning, but it will surely destroy any who uses it as it has condemned us to the terrible fate we now face.



After the grotesque failures of our early experiments, we were foolish to try something more ambitious. But the Doctor insisted that it would work, that the problem was the young age of what we were trying to bring back, that it would be easier to resurrect the distant past. Did he truly believe this? I guess it doesn't matter now. I saw the Old Ones take him.



Yes, we succeeded in bringing back the Old Ones. They're hunting me as I write this journal. We didn't know that they would be so terrible. Perhaps they weren't when they were alive, but the Heart warps everything it brings back. Yet, the Old Ones aren't the worst of what we brought back.



The Heart brought back everything. Everything. The land outside the building in which I hide is the bare and rocky landscape of eons ago before life emerged from the sea. Who knows what lurks in the sea off the shores of the island now? Erupting volcanos fill the air with ash, while earthquakes constantly rock the island. That's our only hope ... that the island will destroy itself before the Old Ones can leave. I hear them coming now."





"The fragment ends there," Tara said. They looked at each other soberly as she finished. The library felt darker than it had been when she began reading the journal.



"That confirms what we've seen the Master do," Giles said. He took off his glasses to polish them. "But is there anything about how to destroy it?"



"There was one other important piece of information I gleaned from the journal," Willow said, walking back and forth as she addressed the group. "It's that the greater the stature of the wielder, the more power he can draw from the Heart. It amplifies your innate powers. Since vampires can't generally cast spells, we've seen only a ghost of what the Heart could do in the hands of someone with real power."



"So he could bring back what exactly?" Spirit asked, not sounding overly worried.



"All sorts of things," Giles began. "Perhaps all the demons that lived here before the Hellmouth was close, or-"



"Oh my God," Willow said slowly, a terrible realization dawning in her eyes. "Buffy!"



"What?" Tara asked, puzzled at first by Willow's exclamation. Then as she realized what Willow was talking about, she softly said, "Oh."



"Last night, she was-" Willow began.



"No," Dawn said firmly, placing a gentle hand on Willow's arm. "It's okay. We cremated her body. There was nothing left to raise left night."



"But what about..." Giles began, then trailed off embarrassedly, realizing that it probably wasn't the best topic to bring up when the person he was about to ask about was sitting across the table from him.



"What about what?" Spirit asked in a slightly annoyed voice as the other three exchanged looks with Giles that indicated that they knew what he was about to say. "Or should I say who?"



"Me," Tara said, looking down at her hands spread on the table. She shuddered as Giles's words conjured an image in her mind of herself as one of the walking dead last night. "He's talking about me." Willow put a comforting hand on Tara's shoulder.



"What?" Spirit exclaimed, more confused than ever.



"Not really you," Dawn said from where she was standing beside Willow. "Your past self."



"Okay," Spirit said as she pushed back her chair and stood up. "Somebody needs to start explaining this now." She looked down at Dawn. "First, who are you and why are you here? I know it's more than you being Buffy's sister."



Tara looked up at Willow, wordlessly asking for her help. "Tara's body is protected by magic," Willow explained, causing Spirit's puzzled annoyance to focus on her instead of Dawn. "The spell wouldn't have been able to affect it either."



Tara let out the breath she hadn't realized that she had been holding in a long sigh. Before she could really feel her relief at the thought that there hadn't been a zombie who looked like her last night, another thought nagged at her mind. What kind of attachment to the past did those spells represent for Willow? Were they still there just to prevent something like last night from happening or were they indicative of deeper feelings?



Giles interrupted before Spirit could say anything. "Tara is the reincarnation of Tara Maclay who was a friend of Dawn and Willow," he said. "We just learned about this recently. I called Dawn to help Tara deal with the news."



"That's why I'm here," Dawn said, looking compassionately at the confused slayer.



"And you believe this?" Spirit asked, turning to face Tara.



"It's true," Tara nodded. She looked anxiously at Spirit, unsure of how her friend would react. Today was the first time she had talked with someone about this who hadn't known her in the past.



"Why didn't you tell me?" she demanded of Tara, but the hurt feelings so evident in her eyes belied the anger of her voice.



"I ... I didn't know what to say," Tara said hesitantly as she met Spirit's brown eyes. "I couldn't quite accept it myself at first. I didn't want you thinking that I was suddenly someone you didn't know ... because I'm not." With a diffident glance at Willow she added, "I'm still me."



"I see," Spirit said, getting up. "You're still my 'friend' who doesn't tell me anything." She walked towards the doors out of the library.



"Wait," Tara pleaded, getting up to follow her. Willow watched uncertainly, not sure whether she should follow along with Tara.



"Don't," Dawn said, gently grabbing Tara's shoulder. "She needs some time."



"Spirit," Giles called out.



"Fill me in when I get back," Spirit said as she went through the doors without a backwards glance.



"Well," Giles sighed. "That could have gone better. I meant to ask you to tell her, Tara, but with everything that happened yesterday..."



"It's okay, Giles," Dawn said. "We understand."



"It's my fault," Willow said, garnering a startled look from Giles. "I shouldn't have brought up that subject."



"No," Tara said, taking Willow's hand. "It's mine. I should have told her. She's my friend."



"It'll be okay," Dawn said, feeling that she'd been saying that a lot lately. "She needs some time to think it over, then she'll be back like she said."



"I hope so," Tara said.



"Trust me," Dawn said, then took off her reading glasses and sat back down in her chair. "Now why is it called the Heart?"



"The full name is the Heart of Corruption," Tara answered, letting Dawn coax her back into research mode as she sat down beside Dawn. She stuck her tongue out. "See, I was doing research."



Giles cleared his throat. "Returning to Willow's statement about it being an amplifier," he said. "If it depends on innate power, why is each spell that he casts more powerful than the last?"



"It takes knowledge to fully utilize any magical artifact," Willow said. "Someone must be teaching him." Her eyes darkened with that thought. She knew too many people who could possess such knowledge, many of whom would be happy to use it to hurt her. She had tried to not leave such loose ends behind her, but over the years they had accumulated. She had paid them little attention, confident that she would be a match for any of them, but now her life was complicated. Wonderfully so, but still complicated.



"Then we have to find out who this teacher is," Giles said firmly. "Unfortunately in Sunnydale there are many candidates."



"True," Willow said with a frown. "What did the three of you find?"



"Dawn found something on the net that may indicate where the heart was found in recent times," Giles said. He gestured in Dawn's direction. "Why don't you read it, Dawn?"



"Okay," Dawn said, looking at the computer terminal in front of her. "It's a lab book entry from a UC Sunnydale professor who was studying the Tunguska site in Siberia."



"It was responsible for the 1908 Tunguska blast?" Tara asked incredulously.



"I don't know," Dawn said. "It may have only been uncovered by the blast. Let me read the entry and you'll see." She hit a few keys and started reading from the screen in front of her.





"I found a most unusual stone in a rocky matrix today near the center of the site. Superficially it looks like an uncut emerald, but is the size of a fist, much larger than any known emerald, and gives off a faint green luminescence. The stone is also intensely cold like nothing else that I've ever found. It is also harder than diamond. We can not chip or cut it with anything we have to take a sample for analysis. We'll have to store it until we get back to the Sunnydale."





Dawn turned the monitor around so that everyone could see the picture of the emerald he was talking about. Clearly it was the same huge emerald-like stone that the Master had held last night.



"Let me guess," Willow said sourly. "He's dead now."



Giles nodded. "He made it back to Sunnydale, but died several days later from 'neck trauma'," he said. "However, there was one more lab entry after he returned. It stated that radioisotope dating indicated that the strata it was found in was Precambrian, but that the object was older than the Earth. They thought something must be wrong with their measurement, but there is another explanation."



"The Old Ones brought it with them when they first came here," Willow said grimly.



"What does that mean?" Dawn asked, wrinkling her brow in puzzlement.



"Before life arose on the earth," Giles lectured. "The Old Ones came down from the stars to live here. The demons and creatures that you fight are their distant descendants. No one really knows much about them except that they were extraordinarily proficient with magic."



"Okay," Dawn said. "But what does that mean about the Heart?"



"It's indestructible," Willow said flatly.



They looked at each other uneasily as Willow's words echoed through the quiet library. How could they defeat something that had survived through all the ages of the world?





* * * * * *






Deep underground, Amy stood in front of the Master's throne, looking up at the now hideous form of the Master. He clung to a semblance of life with terrible tenacity. The skin of his face and neck had melted and flowed like molten wax. One eye, full of emerald fire, peered balefully out of the wreckage of his features. He cradled the Heart in his hands like a beloved child.



"How do you explain your failure?" he demanded, glaring at her with his single eye full of hate. The Heart flared brightly with his anger.



"The Slayer by herself would have fallen, but she had powerful allies we didn't know about," Amy explained in a calm, reasonable tone. "I can show you how to deal with them though" she assured him.



Green fire spilled out of the Heart as he shot up from his throne to shout down at her. "I don't care!" he shouted. "You failed me!" He raised the Heart high to kill her, haloing himself with magical fire.



"The dark witch is coming for you now," Amy warned him without backing down. "Without my help you'll surely die."



The Master glared at Amy, baring his fangs in a terrible grimace, but sank back down into his throne. "What do you suggest?" he asked petulantly.



"I knew this witch in the past," Amy said. "I know the one spectre that can destroy her." She would give the Master what he would think was the key to defeating Willow, but she would keep the real key for herself. And when she used her key, Willow would hand the Heart over to her without a fight.



"We tried that," the Master said with a dismissive wave of his hand.



"Ah," Amy said. "But the Master had been defeated in battle. This time we'll bring back someone who never experienced defeat at the hands of any opponent." She smiled promisingly at the Master as she began to explain the details of her plan.





* * * * * *






For Dawn, it felt like old times as she walked beside Willow through the graveyard. Tara was ahead of them, leading the patrol. Spirit had still been too ill from her encounter with the Heart to go out tonight so they were filling in for her. Dawn was surprised that Willow was so calm about Tara patrolling, especially as point woman, after how she had reacted last night. Thinking about last night brought up a question she'd been waiting to ask Willow.



"Last night," she started. "Tara told you to remember your promise. What did she mean?"



Willow looked over at Dawn for a minute, considering how to answer her question. "I promised to give up dark magic," she said.



"That's great!" Dawn said enthusiastically. Noting the lack of a positive response from Willow, she asked. "It is great, isn't it?"



"I hate that the dark magic takes me away from Tara," Willow admitted. "But sometimes it also offers the best chance to protect her."



"Why?" Dawn asked curiously. "Is dark magic more powerful than light magic?"



"No," Willow said. "But it's easier to gain access to dark magic. With light magic, the price is up front and to draw great power from light sources you have to be doing something that the light powers approve of. Anyone can draw power from dark sources, but the price comes afterwards. It's more dangerous to use, but you have more freedom." Willow didn't mention to Dawn how much easier it had been to use dark magic after she'd pulled Tara's essence from Glory.



"It still sounds like light magic is better," Dawn said cautiously, not wanting to push Willow.



"It usually is," Willow agreed. "But there are some things you can't do with it. Resurrection being one of them." She looked at Dawn with heartfelt regret in her eyes. "Tell me. Could I have saved her if I'd been here?"



"Buffy?" Dawn asked. "You can't blame yourself, Willow. She died of leukemia." Dawn looked sad but proud as she talked about her sister. She had been able to accept her sister's death in a way that Giles hadn't yet and she was proud that no vampire or demon had been able to defeat Buffy.



"I wish I'd been there for her," Willow said with a regretful sigh. She wished she could have seen Buffy one last time.



Dawn reached out to squeeze Willow's hand. "You can't change the past, Willow," she said. It was a platitude, but one that Dawn knew Willow needed to accept in her heart after spending most of her life trying to do just that. "But you can be there for your family in the future. Don't leave us again," she pleaded softly. "I missed you and Tara so much."



"I won't," Willow promised with soft eyes.



"When the Sun's up one day, we could go visit her grave if you want," Dawn offered.



"I'd like that," Willow said with a faint smile. They walked together in companionable silence for a few minutes, watching Tara ahead of them for any warnings of vampiric activity. They actually hadn't seen any vampires tonight. The Master was apparently regrouping after his defeat of the previous night, but it was better to be safe and finish the patrol.



"There was another reason I asked you to come patrol tonight," Willow said to Dawn.



"It wasn't just for the pleasure of my company?" Dawn asked in a mock hurt tone of voice.



"No," Willow smiled. "Though I would've been more than happy to have you for that alone." Her demeanor became very serious as she looked at Dawn. "We can't destroy the Heart, but there's another way to get rid of it."



"Why didn't you mention it at the meeting?" Dawn asked with a puzzled expression on her face. "Does it involve dark magic?"



"Because I need your help," Willow said. "I didn't know how Giles would react to my request."



"My help?" Dawn asked. "What can I do? I'm not a slayer or a witch."



Willow gave Dawn an unfathomable look.



"You're the Key, Dawn."

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

Edited by: darkmagicwillow at: 1/20/03 6:00:25 pm
darkmagicwillow
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby Patches » Mon Jan 20, 2003 11:16 pm

You never cease to amaze me Dark Magic Willow, there's so much in each chapter, so many levels and so many things going on. Splendid writing!



The plot thickens! Great chapter, lays a lot of ground work (and answers questions asked prematurely :blush ). So what are you building here, I asked myself as I read this. You have Amy talking about the "key" to defeating Willow - alluding perhaps to Dawn as the Key, and also alluding to calling a spectre never defeated in battle, and Dawn of course says Buffy died a natural death (ergo, never defeated). Dawn said Buffy was cremated, but the Heart of Corruption is the strongest resurrection talisman ever, so it could still be Buffy (except that the original Master 'killed' her, momentarily - can this be construed as a defeat); but maybe it could be Dawn, because she is both the Key and was created from Buffy matter, and the other references are cleaver red herrings on your part. And now, I'm rambling aimlessly, in the helpless stream of consciousness your story has created in my mind as I try to figure out the clues you've so cleverly hidden. Yes, I know, I'll just have to wait and see how far off base my speculations are.



Enjoyed the opening scene, some nice light humour and interplay between the character. The gesture on Willow's part is touching, a complete work of Tacitus hum, nice present! - what's that master card slogan again, oh ya, can you say priceless :thud



I very much like your Dawn, complete with the nod to reading glasses - nice touch alluding to her age. I wondered at first about Spirit's reaction, then realized that she probably (and rather suddenly) must feel like a bit of an outsider in her own world, and not a little bit betrayed by her friend. I like the way you deal with Tara's other Tara; first the relief that her "former self" wasn't a walking ghoul, and the question that's plagued me for a while, "what kind of attachment to the past did those spells represent for Willow?" I keep wondering how Willow is going to resolve that little mess.



Willow's discussion with Dawn solidified in my mind the thoughts I'd built in the last two updates. Dark magic isn't the only route; it's just the easy route. As for this chapter's cliffhanger - oh whatever are you thinking Willow? On the other hand Dawn, glasses excepted, looks pretty good for someone who is as old as time. One of the things I love most about this story is that it isn't predictable. I never know what you're going to throw out at us, and I am always delighted at what you give us. Never imagined you'd weave Dawn into the story in this light. Nicely done.



Have fun while you’re away! Keep smiling.



Patches



You know I've heard about people like me. But I never made the connection. They walk one road to set them free, And find they've gone the wrong direction. But there's no need for turning back 'cause all roads lead to where I stand. And I believe I'll walk them all No matter what I may have planned

Edited by: Patches at: 1/20/03 9:19:17 pm
Patches
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby deixs » Tue Jan 21, 2003 1:51 am

The key???:thud



Can't wait for more....



Stef :p

deixs
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby JustSkipIt » Tue Jan 21, 2003 7:21 am

Well DMW, disturbing in everything it seems to set up. Seems like angst coming here. I feel bad for Spirit that they didn't tell her about TL=TM but that is very typical for BtVS anyway. That is like a Buffyverse rule: never tell everyone what they need/want to know. That way, you can have a falling out or disaster based on lack of knowledge. One of those things that make me want to bash my forehead when watching. But I digress...



Willow's explanation of Dark Magic vs. Light Magic shed some light but still seems to show her lack of true committment to her promise. Seems like a childish level of committment like as long as she doesn't get caught or if she needs to use it, she will. I've said all this before.



Also, it still seems to me that TL is incapable or unwilling to distinguish between TM and herself. While I understand that she is the reincarnation and shares the same soul, we all do. We all share the same soul with someone (lots of someones) frm before but we don't identify as that person. I think it would be useful to her to identify only as TL and think of TM as "her" rather than "me." The body of TM is just that: the body. Not the soul, essence, or mind.



If Buffy was cremated why will Dawn take Willow to visit her grave? Also, I've never understood why everyone in Sunnydale isn't creamated? Why isn't that just a city ordinance? But I definitely digress...



Ok, I gotta go and earn a living. Great chapter. Debra



Edited to say: PS. Why doesn't Willow ask Dawn about Xander and Anya?

---

"War may be a necessary evil. But no matter how necessary it is always evil." - President Jimmy Carter after receiving the Nobel Peace Prize



"Use your imagination not to scare yourself to death but to inspire yourself to life." - Adele Brookman

Edited by: JustSkipIt at: 1/21/03 5:28:17 am
JustSkipIt
 


Chapter 19b replies

Postby darkmagicwillow » Tue Jan 21, 2003 11:16 am

Patches: Definitely a pricess present, and one I'm happy to see you appreciated. By the way, if you find such a book, I wouldn't mind one either. (-; I'm glad the opening scene worked for you; as you might have noticed, I don't do a lot of that kind of thing.



It's interesting that you asked Tara's question too. Who does Willow think she's dating anyway? Does she even realize what she's doing? Hmmm...maybe I'd better start answering these questions....(-;



deixs: ME may forget about "minor" details like the source of the whole plot of season 5, but I haven't, so yes, the Key.



JustSkipIt: It's difficult for me to write those scenes of misunderstanding, but this one is an honest one. I, and hence Tara, was too busy in previous chapters to get around to telling Spirit about the reincarnation and why these new people who know about the Slayer are suddenly around.



There's still a lot of confusion about Tara's identity on both Tara and Willow's parts. Answers will come bit by bit, as it's a big issue for her to come to grips with and not one they can resolve all at once.



I'm assuming they buried Buffy's ashes and put up a marker in the cemetery. It seems appropriate with how much time she spent there. And Sunnydale could use some city ordinances like that, but perhaps that was one of the Mayor's campaign promises to his dark benefactors.



As for the other Scoobies, Willow's a bit busy with her current issues, but they'll come up eventually.

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

darkmagicwillow
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby tommo » Tue Jan 21, 2003 12:10 pm

I like this shift in tone of the story. In this chapter it seems like you've gone from the exploration of feelings and emotions and character to the exposition of the plot itself. Interesting how you've brought Dawn in as well. The use and analysis of her "keyness" should be quite something. Thanks for this. :)



She's the cutest of the Kittens with her tits as warm as mittens and her firm yet supple...tight embrace...

tommo
 


Re: Chapter 19b replies

Postby Grimlock72 » Tue Jan 21, 2003 1:19 pm

Hmm,



The first thing I noticed was that Amy thought: "Willow would hand the Heart over to her without a fight". That would imply Willow would get the Heart first, which is not logical for Amy to think. Why would she ever give Willow the Heart in the first place ? Does she need Willow to do something to harness the Heart ? (we know that can't be done but Amy likely doesn't have that book)



What bait does Amy intend to use anyway; Willow's kinda wary of resurrections I think... I wonder if she still wants Tara M. back.. "The Heart brought back everything" sounds like a rather dangerous reset button, bit more than a 'simple' resurrection too. I doubt Amy wants to use it for that though, she just wants the power. Wonder what difference another spectre will make, a ghost is a ghost after all... just one with a different display. Willow isn't that impressible that she'll fall for that trick (same goes for Giles, both are way to experienced).



Hmm... I think Giles would have recognized "miss Madison" from the Magic Shop by now, she has been in Sunnydale for how long ? She's a rather obvious teacher for Master jr. :) . How many witches are there in the Sunnydale area ?



Spirit acted rather Dawn-like in this chapter. Soooo horribly upset to be told something 24 hours later than somebody else. Bit annoying that, probably true to age though.



Interesting about the Heart being an amplifier, so it has (almost) no power of it's own ? Given that a vampire has little magic of it's own that must be some amplifier :D . To bad it also sucks out your lifeforce otherwise it would be a usefull tool in proper hands....probably a bit too powerfull for that though.



It being an amplifier also means that the more powerfull the user is the more control he/she must have. If Willow gets upset while holding the Heart she'll level Sunnydale and then some :) . I truly wonder if Amy has much control if it all, she was mostly shown on TV to use magic for short fun spells.



Also liked Willow giving Giles that priceless book, thats the surest way to Giles heart :) . Heh, still have to think about Willow having rooms full of those books in her mansion. Giles would be like a kid in a candystore there.



Liked Willow's view on Dark vs. Light magic, I like pragmatic people. It also happens to neatly coincide with most of my views on the subject, which helps :) . I prefer Willow sticking to Light magic on the basis of such views, as opposed to based on a promise to someone else.



I must say I just don't like Amy (as a charachter) at all in this fic, greedy pathetic witch. Needs a gem like the Heart to actualy be anything, as opposed to Willow who at least worked for her powers. Hopefully Amy will do something stupid and burn to hell while doing some spell which is way out of her reach.... with my luck Willow will end up saving her though : -->>: .



Grimmy

"You hurt Tara," Willow said too calmly. "The last one who tried that was a god. I made her regret it." -- Unexpected Consequences by Lisa of Nine

Edited by: Grimlock72 at: 1/21/03 11:26:21 am
Grimlock72
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby Insanity » Tue Jan 21, 2003 4:14 pm

The Key?? Hah?

I really like this story (am I repeating myself??), it has so many levels.

There is only ONE thing I really miss: Smoochies!!

So, Willow is going to defeat the master, win the heart. And this little bi*** Amy is going to get it by threatening Tara...

Because Tara is the key to Willow...Right??



Insanity

"Nobody messes with my girl!"Tara, Bargaining

Insanity
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby VampNo12 » Tue Jan 21, 2003 8:13 pm

DMW, quite an intriguing update! Enjoyed the gang pulling together to research (especially Dawn alluding to the double meaning of "researching" the W&T way ;) ). Also I'm so glad to see Willow making an effort to relieve some of the tension (a rapprochement) between her and Giles with her "gift", as opposed to exacerbating an already tense situation by trying to settle "old scores" of the past. As for Spirit I can so sympathize with her feelings. Before she was part of the inner-circle (a group formed of Giles, Tara, and herself), and now with the arrival of these two "strangers" she feels like an "outsider" being left out of the loop (ie being the only one not to know about the Tara Lucas/Maclay information).



And yes, issues of identity (the past) again rears it's head with Tara thinking, ("What kind of attachment to the past did those spells represent for Willow? Were they still there just to prevent something like last night from happening or were they indicative of deeper feelings?). It's obvious that doubts/fears still linger, and in order to have a "true" relationship (truly move-on) they need to openly discuss this matter (ie put a final answer to the "Who am I" question). The past has it's place, but they can't recreate the past (relive those memories). Instead they need to trust that their connection/feelings (in the now) are real. With this in mind, they can make new memories, and to look to those moments they create together for hope/strength (ie focus on the here and now, as well as looking towards the future).



Lastly, I am so looking forward to the implications of using the "key", especially with Amy thinking, ("She would give the Master what he would think is the real key to defeating Willow, but she would keep the real key for herself. And when she used her key, Willow would hand her the Heart without a fight."). As well as taking into consideration that Willow needs Dawn's help by saying, ("You're the key, Dawn."). Here I have a feeling the "key" (ie strategy) to truly "defeating Willow" (in Amy's eyes) is taking away Willow's security/"light" (ie Tara). As for Dawn being the "key" I am curious if Willow is alluding to Dawn at one time being the actual "key"? Therefore, I wonder how Dawn being human effects Willow's plans (ie does she need the energy/power of the Key, and if so how will she attain this)? As for the Heart, knowing how it "corrupts" the user, "warps everything it brings back", as well as "amplifying one's innate powers", I look forward to how the gang overcomes this "dark" obstacle (not to mention the reactions of finding out Amy with a grudge is the Master's "teacher", which could influence Willow's dilemma over using dark magic to protect Tara). Can't wait for the next part!

Edited by: VampNo12  at: 1/22/03 2:25:23 am
VampNo12
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby yana » Tue Jan 21, 2003 8:21 pm



I was reading an utterly creepy book late last night and discovered I couldn't go to sleep. So I thought to myself, "I'll check Pens... I'm sure that'll take my mind off the creepy stuff."



HA! So not what happened, because I found chapter 19 with its lovely descriptions of Very Bad Things. Great chapter, as always. I kind of want to slap around Willow until she realizes that she can't hide things from Tara and do what she thinks is best. But you've promised a happy ending so I'm not worried. :)



Yana

yana
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby xita » Tue Jan 21, 2003 8:26 pm

I too noticed the shift now as we shit into the action of the story. W/T seem to have their feelings for each other sorted but there are issues hanging in the air. Willow can't really protect Tara the way she wants her to without tainting her with the very same dark essence that runs through her veins. And while Tara doesn't want her to do dark things anymore, Willow can't think of any other way to keep Tara safe and god sadly she just can't, not fully.

If I had to live my life again, I'd make the same mistakes, only sooner.

Tallulah Bankhead

xita
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby Sister Bertrille » Tue Jan 21, 2003 8:52 pm

Dawn and Amy in a SmackDown, with the Master as the Undertaker! Are you ready to rumble?!!!!!!



I love what all the Pens writers do with Dawn, and you are no exception. It is a stroke of genius to have her be older too, as it makes it likely that the um, few irritating qualities she possessed as a teen (I seem to recall a bit of whining followed by pouting followed by yelling followed by sneaking off directly into the gaping maw of whatever happened to be the biggest threat in Sunnydale that week) would have dissipated, leaving the funny (“I remember the kind of research you two used to do…”), caring (“She’d watched over Spirit carefully today as she was worried about the young woman…”), and intuitive (“‘It still sounds like light magic is better,’ Dawn said cautiously, not wanting to push Willow.”) And what good is being a Key if you can’t take yourself out for a spin every now and then?!



Buffy’s death from leukemia was a sad but valid choice. There are too many natural horrors facing all of us for at least a few of them not to have made their way to Sunnydale. Giles? Not the sharpest knife in the drawer when it comes to recognizing people, is he? Finally, the dialogue here sparkles like cham-pagne (the real kind, none of that Mad Dog 20/20 and club soda).



SB



Sister Bertrille
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby hermitstull » Tue Jan 21, 2003 10:41 pm

Excellent!



So Buffy died of cancer? It's certainly sad but it fits. And it's definately a twist I wasn't expecting.



I really like how you're moving with the new Tara and Willow relationship. They both know that things need to change, especially for Willow, but it's not going to happen overnight. Same thing with Willow and Giles. They seem to want to be friends again, but it's gonna take some time.



great stuff-

hermitstull

"I was feared and worshiped across the mortal globe. At now I'm stuck at Sunnydale High. Mortal. Child. And I'm failing Math." Anya in Dopplegangland

hermitstull
 


More Chapter 19b replies

Postby darkmagicwillow » Wed Jan 22, 2003 8:33 pm

I'm on a rather unreliable DSL connection so my replies might be a bit short this week. It's working okay now, as I edit this, so we'll see how it goes. It shouldn't prevent me from getting you at least one update while I'm gone though.





tommo: Thanks. I'm glad the shift in mood worked.



Grimmy: Amy's betting on Willow defeating the Master after the encounter in the graveyard. Shouldn't she? There's a lot of witches in the Sunnydale area; some of the people at the Wiccan group have talent, and there's always someone new and powerful around like Ethan or Doc.



Interesting questions. What could the Heart offer Willow? What is her Heart's desire?



Insanity: Thanks, and I promise, there will be kisses by the end. Hmmm...was that what Amy meant by the key? You'll have to keep reading.



VampNo12: Keys and hearts. In a way, you could say that's what everything's about in this story. Tara's the key to Willow in so many ways, but both Willow and Tara are unsure if she's precisely the right key. And yes, defeating the Master won't solve all of their problems; the Heart remains.



yana: I'm glad you're not too worried by the creepy stuff. The Heart can be scary.



xita: They want to be together, but those issues are big and they're not focusing on them...yet.



SB: You're not only erudite and sophisticated, but a veritable goddess of pop culture too, I see. (-;



Yes, Dawn had just a few irritating characteristics on the show. Glad you like her here. And thanks so much for your compliments about the dialog. Being an introvert, I have a tendency to wander off into a land of only soliliquies and inner thoughts.



hermistull: Buffy had to be gone in this story, and without repeating the wonderfully appropriate ending of The Gift, this is what I thought would be best. It is sad though.



Overnight? Hmmm....just wait 'til you see what happens tomorrow....

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

Edited by: darkmagicwillow at: 1/22/03 8:36:07 pm
darkmagicwillow
 


Re: Chapter 19b: Secrets

Postby Grimlock72 » Thu Jan 23, 2003 3:07 pm

Ah yes, Willow defeating Master jr. Given his condition last time on the graveyard I estimate Master jr. wont life long enough to meet Willow at all. That would simplify Amy's plan to; pick up Heart crystal from between the dust :D



One other thing; suppose Willow has the heart why would she give it to Amy ? Assuming all that is written about it is true, the Heart should have enough power to let Willow handle any threat or problem. As opposed to Master jr. , Willow really doesn't need a teacher like Amy to do usefull things with the Heart :D



Granted, using the Heart has a price of course but still.... and indeed what DOES Willow want so very much she would give Amy such a powerfull object like the Heart of Corruption ?? Interesting question... which is true of the whole story btw. lots of interesting things in it.



Doing anything to resurrect Tara M. is rather risky for Tara L. I would think. I suppose Willow might want to go back to her pre-dark-magic days (i.e. go back to the point where she's in sync with Tara L so to speak), question is if thats worth giving Amy the gem and if she really wants to drop 20 years of hard work (granted, lots of bad memories too)...



Hmm... I might be better of just waiting for the next chapter, thinking about all the options is rather headeache inducing :D



Have fun where-ever you're going btw. (hopefully some place warmer than here)



Grimmy :wave

"You hurt Tara," Willow said too calmly. "The last one who tried that was a god. I made her regret it." -- Unexpected Consequences by Lisa of Nine

Edited by: Grimlock72 at: 1/23/03 1:12:16 pm
Grimlock72
 


Re: More Chapter 19b replies

Postby Tulipp » Thu Jan 23, 2003 4:02 pm

Oh yes, I remember realizing for the first time that the Heart is both the Heart and, you know, THE HEART. And I had this moment where I was an intro to lit student all over again realizing that there's no such thing as a "hidden meaning"; there are just layers of meaning. In this case, the layers of meaning around the heart are huge. I love this exchange in particular:

Quote:
"But what does that mean about the Heart?"

"It's indestructible," Willow said flatly.




Because yes, of course, Heart of Corruption, gem, soul, evil, Master, etc. But then also...Willow's and Tara's hearts, love, perseverence, soulmates, etc.



Pretty incoherent at the moment, but I also like Willow's understatedness when she hands that book over to Giles and just says "now it's found" in a light voice. Perfect characterization there.

"And I'm eating this banana. Lunchtime be damned!" -- Willow in "Doppelgangland

Tulipp
 


Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby darkmagicwillow » Thu Jan 23, 2003 9:44 pm

I'm a little slow being away from home, but here's the first part of chapter 20. I'll answer the last replies to chapter 19 in a little bit.





Title: The Dark Rose - Chapter 20a (Three Small Words)

Author: Dark Magic Willow

Email: darkmagickwillow@yahoo.com

Rating: R, mostly for violence, no explicit sex

Pairing: W/T

Spoilers: All episodes through the end of season 6 though this story takes place 18-19 years after the end of season 6.

Feedback: Yes! Constructive criticism is always welcome.

Summary: Realizations and choices.

Magic Note: Magic, even dark magic, is not addictive in my universe, so there are no withdrawal symptoms and no dark magic dealers. Here Rack was a dark magic teacher who used his students, not a dealer. However, you can use too much magic and you can be corrupted by the power it gives you.

Disclaimer: I don't own any of the copyrights or anything else associated with BtVS. All rights lie with the production company, writers etc.

Acknowledgements: Thanks to Amanda and Juli for so much wonderful feedback on this chapter





The Dark Rose

Chapter 20a: Three Small Words






Tara steadily sorted the heaps of clothes on the floor of Willow's bedroom into colors and whites, normals and delicates. When she had awakened this morning, she had decided to create some order in here. Willow had readily agreed to her plan, sounding as happy as she was to be doing something as mundane as cleaning house with her. They'd been working up here until a few minutes ago when Willow had gone downstairs to put a new load of clothes in the washer and find some lunch for the two of them.



Knowing Willow, lunch was either going to be sandwiches or delivery food. She wasn't into cooking, claiming that she'd sustained herself on magic alone for months at a time, and Tara hadn't gotten around to exploring the kitchen of the mansion yet. Knowing that vampires lived here for years before Willow, she thought it might require a considerable amount of work to make it serviceable.



As she pulled a pair of jeans from her current pile, the adjacent heap of clothes collapsed. A small black leather bound book fell out, opening to a page near the beginning. She glanced down at the open page and saw a poem in Willow's handwriting. It was short, and she couldn't stop herself from reading it even as she realized that this book was Willow's diary.





Glorious was the sun that shone

Now darkness falls, light is gone

The grieving moon weeps for the light

But forever is the dark of this night

Sleep's solace forbidden me

A nightmare of eternity





Her throat was tight and she felt like she was about to cry as she finished the poem. How had Willow found the strength to make it through all those years alone? That kind of dedication, to live without home, friends, or even eating was difficult to imagine. It wasn't something that Tara thought that she could do herself. And she didn't know if anyone, much less herself, could be worthy of such devotion.



Most of the time, Tara forgot the years that divided them, but then something like this would happen to remind her, tearing her out of her happy world with Willow in the present. One moment she was folding clothes; the next she was reading about Willow's grief over her death, a grief that had gone on for Tara's whole life, almost the nightmare of eternity the poem spoke of.



The darkness surrounding Willow wasn't simply that of the magic. Willow was shrouded by years of grief and loneliness that Tara could feel every time they touched. Those feelings lightened with her presence, but never went away entirely, and as she read Willow's journal she could feel the shadows of those feelings seeping into her.



She wondered what Willow thought of the years between them. What would it take for their weight to be lifted from her? Why wasn't finding Tara again enough? Was there anything in this journal that would stop those shadows from haunting the two of them?



Did Willow think of her as one and the same as the Tara of old or were there two different Tara's in her mind? She had difficulty seeing the difference herself sometimes, but more than anything she wanted Willow to love her for herself, not for the memories or obligations of the past.



Tara looked down at the poem again. This little book held so many of the answers she was seeking, maybe even the one to her most important question. Did Willow love her for yourself? Should she invade Willow's privacy and read it? The obvious answer was no, but this diary could be the key to pulling Willow out of the darkness, to bringing them together without barriers. How could she not read it?



Tara felt that they could only put the past behind them and move forward if she actually knew what had happened. Her visions had shown her some of it, but she felt that she was still missing too much. Willow wasn't very helpful, talking about the places she'd visited and the things she'd learned, but only rarely discussing the people she'd met. She was even reluctant to discuss the other Tara with her. Why? What did that mean about how Willow saw her? Somewhere in Willow's recollections of the past, Tara felt that she could find what she needed to reconcile her two identities. Now that information was sitting in front of her in a little book.



She flipped forward through the journal, her hands seemingly moving of their own volition as if she hadn't made a conscious decision to do this. She skimmed past more poetry and short, heartbreaking descriptions of grief that Willow hadn't been able to share with anyone. Who would she have had to share them with? She had left home and family behind her. One particularly poignant entry stopped her for a moment.



I realized today that I can't remember how she smelled. I used to love how she smelled. There were the scents of incense and herbs from her rituals and spices from cooking and something undefinably Tara underlying it all, but I can only describe it now. I can't bring forth the smell in my mind any longer. It's only been a year, and I miss you so much, Tara. I will bring you back. I promise.




Tara wondered if she still smelled the same. Then she wondered if she wanted to. It had been disturbing enough looking at a picture of a young woman who could have been her sister and being told that it was her. Did she want to smell the same too? Would there be anything left of her that was hers alone?



Yet how could she not want to answer that cry of grief? It made her want to fold Willow close in her arms and tell her that everything was all right, that she was back and that she would never leave Willow again. She wanted to be able to do even more than that. She wished she could have been there for Willow all those years she'd been without her, but that would mean that she'd never lived her life. How could she give up her life, her family, everything that was her, even for Willow?



As she thought about Willow being alone all the years of Tara's life, for the first time it really hit her what that meant. When she had her first birthday party, Willow had been writing this journal entry in solitary grief. When she was in high school, Willow had been in Hell looking for her as she had seen in her vision. For every happy moment of her life, playing, reading, learning magic from her mother, there had been a dark, grieving one in Willow's.



Tara put the book down and stood up, unable to read any further. The aching in her throat and the tightness in her chest made her feel like she couldn't breathe. This dark revelation kept sinking deeper into her, piling its weight of grief on her heart, as if it had no end. She blinked away the tears that threatened to fall. Looking down at the leather bound pages, she realized that it wasn't simply a book. It was a repository for all the grief that Willow had felt over the years.



The journal seemed unnaturally heavy, weighed down by its contents of grief and despair, as she picked it up again and placed it in her lap as she sat back down on the bed. She looked down on the book without turning the page for a long moment.



It had to be enough, for her, for Willow, that they had found each other in this life. There had to be a reason that fate had brought them together when no amount of magic, dark or light, could have, but no matter how many times she told herself this she still worried that Willow couldn't accept her this way. Willow had been so attached to the past. Her whole life had been wrapped around righting what had happened that terrible day.



Tara slowly turned the page and began reading again, unable to tear herself away from the journal despite the pain it brought her. She felt compelled to understand what Willow had gone through. A long entry caught her attention about a quarter of the way through the book.





I have left her.



I didn't think it would be so hard. Why does it hurt? I didn't love her. We came together for comfort. We made no promises. Should I feel guilty about that? We had both lost so much. We were the same.



Or were we? She was so beautiful, so persuasive. I learned more of the art from her than I had from anyone. Step-by-step, naturally I felt, I came to share her dream. Of dreams. To open the Sea of Dreams and let the stuff of dreams into reality. Together we would reshape the world. All of heaven and earth she promised.



Would it have worked? Can dreams be harnessed to serve our conscious mind or would the sharp, bitter clarity of reality have been dissolved forever into the fuzzy insubstantiality of dreams? I don't know. It doesn't matter now. Without me she cannot open the gates of horn and ivory.



As we worked towards our goal, side by side in her library, we talked about our dreams. At first all I said was Tara, but Arien kept asking me questions. Wouldn't I have liked Tara not to have left me for using dark magicks? Wouldn't I have like Tara to be more beautiful? Each question seemed reasonable by itself, yet step-by-step my image of Tara changed into one of Arien. Did she love me? I think that she did. Yet that wouldn't have stopped her from using me to open the portal of dreams any more than any feeling on my part would stop me from resurrecting Tara.



In the end, I realized that a dream, however beautiful or substantial, wasn't the Tara that I loved. It has to be the real Tara, no matter what the price. But I wonder, when I find her, will I be like Arien, lost too deep in the dark for her to love me?





Tara's first feeling was jealousy, sharp and hot. Did coming together for comfort mean what she thought it did? What had happened to Willow's supposedly undying devotion to her?



No, she was jumping to conclusions. She didn't know for certain what had happened. Then another thought stopped her. She wanted Willow to have had some comfort in all those years of solitude and grief. How could she resent Willow for having found that? Suddenly she felt very selfish and guilty. And there was the last line showing that Willow had wanted the real Tara, her soulmate, not an illusion or a better version of her.



But was she the real Tara?



That was her real question. Was she the real Tara that Willow loved?



She flipped to the last entry in the journal, searching for answers in the book that had only brought her more questions, hoping that in the ending there would be the answers that Willow had found in her dark journey. She began reading.





After all these years I found her and I don't know what to do. I hadn't given this part much thought. It was supposed to be a fairy tale ending where we lived happily ever after. At the very least, I expected her to recognize me. It's her, yet it isn't her.





This part was comforting in an odd way. She had been so deeply immersed in her own confusion that she hadn't thought about Willow's. Willow had all these expectations about their reunion and nothing had happened as she had envisioned it. That had to be confusing and painful. Maybe they could find their answers together. She liked that idea.



It hurt to read about Willow's disappointment at meeting her. It wasn't her fault that she hadn't recognized Willow. If she had been able to see her face she might have recognized her from her dreams, but her dreams had never given her a name to go with that face. Still, she had to admit that she would have felt the same if Willow hadn't recognized her.





There was no resurrection. A resurrection is a returning. This is a new turning. Yet I could still perform the resurrection, return her soul to Tara's body. Would it be saving her life or the most terrible crime I've ever committed? Would she love me if I did such a thing?





Her blood chilled as she read this paragraph. Had Willow really thought of doing that to her? She read on, desperate to find a different answer in Willow's journal.





Whether or not she would, I can't do it. She's too much of the Tara I love.





She sighed with relief, feeling her shoulders unknot as she did so, as she read those words. Willow hadn't really thought about doing that to her after all. Still, a sense of unease lingered over her from reading those words in Willow's handwriting. She hurried on to the last sentence, trying to dispel her uneasiness.





Yet can I love her? Would I be faithful to my Tara if I did?





Her face fell as she finished reading the entry. She had her answer. Willow did think of her and the past Tara as separate, but she didn't love her and wasn't sure that she ever could. Unable to dismiss the shadow of the past as mere memory any longer, she shivered as she felt her heart enveloped in its chill embrace. Her fingers cold and almost numb, she let the cruel book slip out of her fingers to land on the floor with a thump.

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

Edited by: darkmagicwillow at: 1/25/03 8:17:01 pm
darkmagicwillow
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby Patches » Fri Jan 24, 2003 12:40 am

Well now DMW, “just wait until you see what happens tomorrow,” you promised us a roller coaster ride, and you certainly delivered. This chapter, above all else you have written, is the one that has left me cold. The implications of the choices that are made here are far more chilling than a street full of zombies.



Have to admit, I’m quite angry with Tara. I hear my own questions echoed in Tara’s words, why wasn’t finding her enough. Well, she should know that it’s not quite that simple. Questions of the soul’s journey are indeed complex, in life and in death, in light and in darkness. Perhaps Giles should have given Tara some of the more hefty tomes to help her understand what was going on. She has her answer in her question – why wasn’t finding her enough.



Reading Willow’s journal? The answers are not going to be found in the darkest musings of a tormented soul, in words never intended to see the light of day. Bad thing to do, it’s so easy to misinterpret private and often incomplete thoughts, ascribe motive when none exists, and this is exactly what Tara’s doing. I hate to say it, but if she makes assumptions based on a partial reading, little snippets of another person’s most inner musings, well – she’s going to get what she deserves, incomplete answers, more questions, more confusion and invalid conclusions. Rather than quieting her fears, she’s fuelling them. I liked the reversal of the imagery, of darkness descending on Tara, though I, unequivocally, do not like its motivation.



Wanting, no needing to know who Willow is in love with is

so important to this story. “Should she invade Willow's privacy and read it? The obvious answer was no, but this diary could be the key to pulling Willow out of the darkness, to bringing them together without barriers. How could she not read it?" When faced with the choice “how could she not” read Willow’s diary, she chose – poorly. Her motivation is pure, but the action is suspect. When I read that section, I immediately thought, in response, how could Willow not use dark magic when the time came. Is it really all about the easy answers, taking the easy road? Tara knows Willow stood at the gates of hell, she knows she bears the soul of Tara Maclay; she is the reason for Willow darkness. I hate to get all proverbial, but I am reminded of the lesson, the road to hell is paved with good intention. Tara’s betraying Willow with this action, and I’m not very comfortable with it. She feels selfish and guilty – good, as well she should.



Interesting the play of fate, finding the diary, fate or happenstance; I almost feel like the darkness in this story has taken on a life all its own, reluctant to give up its hold and is ‘fighting’ back, tempting Tara – nothing says that “fate” has to be kind. I am sorry she took the bait, now two souls journey in darkness.



“Unable to dismiss the shadow of the past …” there’s that play with light imagery again. Most appropriate here as well. That’s all Tara sees is shadows, and with her conclusion embraces the cold chill of ignorance. “Yet can I love her? Would I be faithful to my Tara if I did?” Tara didn’t get the answer she was looking for, but perhaps got the answer she deserved. Yes, I know, that’s rather a cold thing to say but deception and duplicity rarely leads to truth and enlightenment. However, I understand the temptation and why she succumbed to it – nothing says I have to like it (lol).



Hey, I think you got me all fired up with this chapter (ya think – lol). The opening poem in Willow’s diary was powerful in its simplicity, yet so rich in imagery. I did like how you moved the story forward with the diary, and gave us more insight into her past – opening the world of dreams, now that’s a chilling thought.



As always, thank you for the story, it is the richest and most complex story I’ve had the pleasure to read in a very, very long time. I love the philosophical undercurrents that run through the story. Looking forward to next week’s update, oh and if I happen across an original Tacitus, it’s yours.



Cheers!!

Patches



ETA: I need a refresher course on how to use an apostrophe :blush :blush :blush - think I got 'em all this time.

You know I've heard about people like me. But I never made the connection. They walk one road to set them free, And find they've gone the wrong direction. But there's no need for turning back 'cause all roads lead to where I stand. And I believe I'll walk them all No matter what I may have planned

Edited by: Patches at: 1/24/03 4:48:57 pm
Patches
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby deixs » Fri Jan 24, 2003 1:52 am

Oh My god!



What a cliffhanger......

I hope Tara doesn't assume too much and talks to Willow about this entry. I think Willow loves her.



Stef :p

Edited by: deixs at: 1/24/03 7:37:34 am
deixs
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby Grimlock72 » Fri Jan 24, 2003 5:07 am

Heh, I would like to thank Patches for writing part of my feedback for me :D



The diary... of course it had to surface sooner or later. Tara does think she can't get answers by asking Willow, problem with that is that I've hardly ever seen her ask. I'm not so sure she tried all that hard, she's shy and a bit intimidated by Willow I think... so getting information the indirect way is easier. Thats not to say that information will be easy to handle...



I really liked the poem at the beginning, which is rather unique for me since I hardly ever like poems. Helps if you know what the poem is based on I guess.



I'm assuming the lady in the library was the same one Tara had a vision about, sure looks like her. I liked that Tara felt jealous at her, which turned into guilt in about 2 seconds. The spell Willow and the Lady intented to do sounds rather drastic, turning dreams into reality... lets hope those are only happy dreams...



It must be confusing for Tara L., she didn't exactly ask to be Tara the 2nd after all. I found her thoughts on that touching: "Would there be anything left of her that was hers alone?"... she's her own guardian in that regard (how much does she want to change to have Willow love her, does she need to change at all??).



Tara L's reaction to Willow considering resurrecting Tara M was a bit different from mine. Likely comes from knowing Willow a bit longer, but Willow would eventually have thought about that anyway. Might as well consider it and discard the idea early on.



That decision effectivly ends Willow quest to get her Tara back though.



Tara L isn't exactly the poster-girl for privacy now is she ? First that spell which happened to look into Willow's life "between Tara's" and now reading a diary... neither of which has been talked about with Willow yet. Sensing a lack of trust here, from both girls really. Willow should tell Tara L. things she asks about without holding back if she really wants to start any type of relation with her. And Tara L. should ask what she wants to know and damn well insist on answers and not crawl into a corner on getting an unsatisfactory answer.



Their a bit too friendly/carefull at the Q&A and it's driving them apart if they're not carefull.



Grimmy

"You hurt Tara," Willow said too calmly. "The last one who tried that was a god. I made her regret it." -- Unexpected Consequences by Lisa of Nine

Grimlock72
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby JustSkipIt » Fri Jan 24, 2003 8:02 am

Wow and also wow DMW. I was just about to say that you are posting so often and your note says sorry slow? Ok. sounds good to me.



Gut wrenching!



First, I had been wondering if Willow was living in Angel's mansion. Looks like it.



Second, the poem is perfect with the imagery of the light and the moon. Good incorporation.



While I don't like TL reading the diary -- bad TL, no cookie! -- I do like the internal dialog she carries on. Great questions she's asking. Now ask them of Willow! The most heartbreaking part of the journal to me is about smell. I am smell-oriented and that's what scares me the most: when I would lose the scent of someone. I was crying when I read that because it fits so perfectly for me.



I find it interesting that both girls use the word "love" so casually to think of their feelings for each other and the other's feelings for them but don't actually say that. Glad that TL wants to be a separate person from TM and that Willow sees her that way, but... seems more complicated than that.



Ok, I'm not that smart today with my feedback because no good sleep. Great part! :clap :clap :clap

Debra

---

"War may be a necessary evil. But no matter how necessary it is always evil." - President Jimmy Carter after receiving the Nobel Peace Prize



"Use your imagination not to scare yourself to death but to inspire yourself to life." - Adele Brookman

JustSkipIt
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby barnabasvamp » Fri Jan 24, 2003 11:36 am

Such conflicting emotions for Tara. Wants to be herself, not the old Tara, but when she reads Willow's thoughts she is disturbed to find that Willow does see them as two separate beings. Wow.



Really looking forward to where you are taking all this.

BV

"In front of total strangers won't you kiss me, Flowers for no reason but you miss me - OOH, I wanna be in love"Melissa Etheridge

barnabasvamp
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby frumpycat » Fri Jan 24, 2003 12:13 pm

Pretty much Patches summed up everything I thought concerning the Tara/Journal/trust issue (and then some...nice one Patches). It almost reminds me of trying to read someone’s mind against their will. And as Patches pointed out, she only got snippets and was drawing conclusions on what the author’s motivations were. Could it have hurt to ask Willow if she could read her journal? To share it and explain what she was thinking when she wrote it? To share her fears and experiences so that Tara could better understand them? That sounds more like the foundation of a trusting relationship than rummaging through Willow’s personal effects.



BTW I’m like Grim…not the biggest poetry fan but that poem was pretty darn good. Is it yours? If so…damnnnnn…talented as all heck.



frumpycat
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby sheila wt » Fri Jan 24, 2003 6:23 pm

Patches, you seem to be the voice of the Kittens here... :) You pretty much said everything that went through my mind after I finished this chapter, much better than I could ever do, of course.



DMW, I can't even begin to say what a masterpiece this story is. When I read that you're going to be away for 2 weeks and there would be less updates, my heart sank... I was so surprised (and happy) to find this last chapter this morning! :bounce :bounce :bounce



I feel like I could read this wonderful piece of writing forever... (don't think you could write it forever though, life can be "a little" demanding sometimes... ;) )





--------------------------
"She had tasted Willow on her tongue, and she had worn Willow on her skin. There wasn't a shower in the world that could have washed that away." (Terra Firma, by Tulipp)

sheila wt
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby VampNo12 » Fri Jan 24, 2003 7:23 pm

DMW what a heart-wrenching, as well as insightful update! I think this line, ("Most of the time, Tara forgot the years that divided them, but then something like this would happen to remind her, tearing her out of her happy world with Willow in the present."), sums up well that the "past" is the "big elephant in the room" until they truly learn to communicate with each other. Or in other words, I agree with Patches great feedback that it seems that both W&T are opting for the less painful, easier path (Tara invading Willow's privacy instead of truly talking with her, as well as Willow's belief that she will have to go back on her promise because dark magic is really her only option to protect Tara rather than finding other avenues) instead of together working through the struggle of a harder option where the rewards in the long-run will be greater/more beneficial (ie be able to truly move-on and bask in the "light", a future).



I do understand Tara's motivations, (her need) to read Willow's private journal, (ie it's not completely selfish, "....but the diary could be the key to pulling Willow out of the darkness, to bringing them together without barriers."). Willow hasn't been too forthcoming with details, so on the one hand Tara feels this may be her only real chance to gain some insight by reading Willow's unguarded thoughts in order to help her. However, by the same token each has been "beating around the bush", by talking around the issues, so if Tara wants answers to her questions she really should go to the source (Willow). Really most of Willow's journal was written during a very dark period, where hope of a brighter tomorrow seemed an improbablility, thus interpreting Willow's words is a risky proposition. Therefore, to get a true understanding of what Willow is thinking/feeling she should rely on hearing it from the "horses mouth", and not try to assign meaning to the words found in the diary.



I must say you imagery is simply amazing, and that poem so resonated with me. You truly make Willow's grief/pain so palpable to me. And what struck a chord were these lines, ("As she thought about Willow being alone all the years of Tara's life, for the first time it really hit her what that meant. When she had her first birthday party, Willow had been writing this journal entry in solitary grief. When she was in high school, Willow had been in Hell looking for her as she had seen in her vision. For every happy moment of her life, playing, reading, learning magic from her mother, there had been a dark grieving one in Willow's."). Wow, this conveys so well that while Tara Lucas was experiencing life (living, reveling in the joy/etc), Willow was clinging to a memory, a grief that would never fade until she could bring her back. I guess what I'm trying to say for Tara (who at the time was blissfully unaware) her life continued on, and now with learning about the past (ie Tara Maclay) she needs to make sure she doesn't lose the identity that shaped her life, made her the person she is today (ie you can't recreate the past).



Lastly, I was intrigued with Willow's passage about Arien, and I could understand Tara's inner-battle of feeling jealously to whatever role this woman played in her life, while at the same time glad that this woman might of offered a little respite from the grief ("a moment of comfort"). And I think what speaks volumes about Willow choosing Tara over the all-consuming power Arien could offer (ie "To open the Sea of Dreams and let the stuff of dreams into reality.") was Willow writing, ("In the end, I realized that a dream, however beautiful or substantial, wasn't the Tara I loved."). As for Tara thinking she found the answer she was seeking with "Willow did think of her and the past Tara as separate, but she didn't love her and wasn't sure that she ever could.", that was quite a crushing "blow". Here her fear is relieved in one sense, but than the "power" of those final words take away any hope/belief that they have a future together. Really saying "I love you" can be the hardest words to say, but even if Tara takes Willow's words as "gospel", Willow's actions towards her should tell her the truth (ie Willow indeed loves her). Although, doubts/fears can and will "cloud" a person from seeing the truth, and that's why they really need to trust each other by sharing their concerns/doubts (ie believe that together they have the strength to overcome their obstacles). Can't wait for the next part!

Edited by: VampNo12  at: 1/24/03 8:45:13 pm
VampNo12
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words - feedback

Postby Sister Bertrille » Fri Jan 24, 2003 8:31 pm

And in this corner, Tara “Pandora” Lucas, who unlike her namesake (another difference between the two?) never met a lock she wouldn’t pry, a past she wouldn’t scry, a diary she wouldn’t read (“I swear to God, it fell open when I was cleaning” – oh, wait, that was me… :) ), a “Do Not Disturb” sign she wouldn’t quietly flip over... If I didn't know better, I'd say that she and my little sister...nah, couldn't be.



As Crash Davis said in Bull Durham, “You’re gonna have to learn your clichés. You’re gonna have to study them, you’re gonna have to know them.” Here are a few for Tara Lucas, who is not above taking a few “black magicky” shortcuts of her own: “Don’t go there.” “Thanks but that’s more information than I need to know.” “Abandon every hope, all you who enter.” “Ticket, please.” “Never ask a question to which you don’t know the answer.” “No trespassing.” “Jacket required.” “Curiosity kil…” oops, never mind, sorry, Kittens! “Under 17 requires accompanying parent or adult guardian.” “No boys allowed!”



And the most important one of all: “You must be at least this tall to go on this ride!”



One question: If Willow was being unfaithful with Arien, to whom would she have been unfaithful – Tara Maclay, who was dead, or Tara Lucus, whom she had never met?



Leap before you look (in someone else's diary – you hear that, sister mine?!),



SB

Sister Bertrille
 


Replies, 19 and 20

Postby darkmagicwillow » Fri Jan 24, 2003 9:51 pm

That was the last part I had mostly done before I left home. I'm working on the next part in a house with friends to talk with when their two very young children aren't being even more distracting so it's going a bit slowly. They're good distractions though. I'll try to have something next week, but no guarantees as to which day.



I won't make it through all the replies tonight, but I will get to everyone this weekend.



Grimmy: The Heart is powerful, but it can't be easily made to serve other ends.



Tulipp: I really like what you have to say about the Heart, and especially your description of your realization that there are no hidden meanings, only layers of meanings. That's something I discovered while writing, or rather rewriting actually, realizing that I had said more than I had originally meant or meant more than I had originally said in places. Now I get another level of meanings as I read all the feedback posts on this story and get a better understanding of my own writing which is not something I expected in the beginnining.



Patches: You describe so well why Tara's actions here are a mistake, how's she misleading herself as well as betraying Willow's trust. I think that VampNo12 explains above why her actions aren't completely selfish, and in her defence, she is quite young and having a complex, difficult first experience with love. I can't defend what she did, but I can defend her as a person who is worthy of loving, who can understand the mistake she made that, as you point out, she's already beginning to suffer the consequences of.



Oh, and I love your image of the dark taking a life of its own and fighting back to pull them back in. Quite creepy. Thanks for your insight on the depth of the meaning and reprecussions of this moment; it's helped me understand this scene better myself. And thanks in advance for the Tacitus, should you find it. (-;



deixs: I love your faith in Willow, how you make that leap with hope in your heart. Tara's had the courage to begin the leap, but as she sees the depths of the chasm under her flying body, she's beginning to have doubts now that it's too late to return unscathed to her point of beginning.



Grimmy (again ;-): Yes, Arien is the lady in white from Tara's vision. Their spell wouldn't have been good for the world, though it might have brought them everything they dreamed it could for a time.



You've found Tara's primary fear in this quote:

Would there be anything left of her that was hers alone?
She wants the love that she can almost touch so much, but she's afraid that the price for her heart's desire will be her heart itself. Is that a price she can pay?



JustSkipIt:Thanks for the 'wows.' The entry about forgetting how Tara smelled came from personal experience. It was a moment of shock and grief for me, forgetting that. *hugs* for the tears.



Your comment about how easily they think about loving each other, but how they've never said it, is a poignant thought that highlights the source of the difficulties in their relationship as well as the title of this chapter.



barnabasvamp: You're right. Tara is very conflicted here, and it's a conflict that has to be resolved inside her, not in the words of a journal or in the outcome of a spell.



frumpycat: The poem is mine. I'm really happy you liked it. I think that was the part of the whole story I was most self conscious about. Of course, you haven't seen the poems I threw out....

--

"Omnia mutantur, nihil interit." -- "Everything changes, but nothing is truly lost."

Edited by: darkmagicwillow at: 1/25/03 7:28:39 pm
darkmagicwillow
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby FlereImsaho » Sat Jan 25, 2003 1:44 am

Oh my God I'm crying! I cannot WAIT for the next chapter! I've got to find time to read this during the week.

FlereImsaho
 


Re: Chapter 20a: Three Small Words

Postby The Inward Sea » Sat Jan 25, 2003 9:55 pm

Oh, boy! Not much room for analysis here -my mind is full of questions and amazement- but how I LOVE this! It's a wonderful ride. This last update broke my heart, but in a good way :) I like Tara reading Willow's diary, it shows a grade of trust -with some apprehension too- that I like.



I won't get tired of praising your writing skills. Will you get tired of hearing them? :)



Sea



"The universe is an iceberg, and all that we can see and touch just the tip above a deep sea." darkmagicwillow -the Kitten-.

Edited by: The Inward Sea at: 1/25/03 7:56:03 pm
The Inward Sea
 

PreviousNext

Return to Board index

Return to Willow/Tara Finished Fics Archive (Authors #s, A-M)

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 18 guests


Powered by phpBB The phpBB Group © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007
Style based on a Cosa Nostra Design